In the fast-paced world of social media influencers, few stories capture the magic of second chances like that of Carli Bybel and Brett Caprioni. On January 2, 2026, the couple shared joyous news on Instagram: an engagement, sealed with a sparkling oval-shaped diamond ring during a New Year’s Eve celebration. This milestone came just 75 days after they publicly confirmed rekindling their romance on October 17, 2025, Bybel’s 35th birthday.
Bybel, a popular YouTube beauty vlogger, and Caprioni, known for his fitness content and a stint on Vanderpump Rules, first dated from 2013 to 2017 before an amicable split. Their time apart allowed personal growth, leading to a reunion that felt fated.
Bybel described their story as one that “pauses, grows, heals, and returns stronger,” while Caprioni echoed that their love was “too real” to fade. This swift path from reconciliation to commitment highlights resilience and timing in modern relationships, inspiring fans worldwide with its blend of nostalgia and new beginnings.
Roots of a lifelong connection: From kindergarten to a couple
Carli Bybel and Brett Caprioni’s story doesn’t start from the levels of social media fame, but began way back when they attended kindergarten in New Jersey. In many ways, such a beginning laid the foundation for this bond, which had lasted decades. Growing up, their friendship blossomed into romance when they began dating in 2013. At that moment in time, Carli Bybel was building her career as a YouTube beauty content creator, amassing millions of followers with makeup tutorials and lifestyle videos.
Caprioni, on the other hand, was establishing himself in the fitness world, sharing workout tips and motivational posts. It was their shared East Coast roots and mutual passions for health and creativity that brought them closer together during those early years. As a team for four years, the two faced the trials and tribulations that came with increasing fame while being each other’s support systems. They frequently shared a glimpse into their lives on social media platforms, ranging from date nights to ideas about content collaboration.
Their chemistry and support system impressed fans. These were the early stages of exploration and achievements as they settled into new relationships amidst their personal goals. Caprioni later spoke about these early stages as definitive moments in his life. As Carli Bybel said about his early stages with Caprioni, these were the moments that defined the early relationship that eventually came with its trials and tribulations.
Navigating separation: growth after the split
In 2017, Carli Bybel and Caprioni made the decision to end their relation with each other after four successful years together. The decision to split was a mutual and respectful one; Bybel revealed in a YouTube video last November in a Q&A session with her followers,” People change, and people grow apart.” Bybel and Caprioni had a connection so deep and so rich that it seemed to be normal for them to remain friends as a matter of health and functionality.
The subsequent years saw major developments in her personal life. Carli Bybel enjoyed much success in her field. She established her own makeup brand. Additionally, she gave birth to a child in 2021, EN: which is an addition to her rich experiences. Caprioni, on the other hand, appeared on reality television shows. He featured on ‘Vanderpump Rules’ and made a name for himself in the entertainment industry.
He would later call the split “one of the most difficult experiences” he had ever had to endure, but said he never really moved on from the relationship, but simply waited for a chance reunion. This is the time of separation during which each is able to develop himself or herself, Carli Bybel on being a good mother and businesswoman, Caprioni on broadening his career base through emotional introspection. Without the strain of the relationship to contend with, each one can develop goals to improve his or her life, oblivious to the forthcoming resurgence.
A swift reunion: From rekindling to forever
By October 2025, Carli Bybel and Caprioni were pulled back to each other, solidifying their renewed romantic relationship on October 17, 2025. Bybel’s TikTok video, posted in celebration of her birthday, showed Caprioni presenting Bybel with roses in what was labeled as the love story of “healing and coming back stronger.” Caprioni’s reaction in the Instagram post expanded upon their lifelong connection when he stated he had always believed they were
“meant to find each other again” since their love was “too real” to ever truly let it die out, and instead was “continuing the story that was always ours.” Only 75 days later, on December 31, 2025, Caprioni proposed to Bybel during a New Year’s Eve party. Carli Bybel accepted the ring, which was an oval-shaped diamond ring, later stating it was the “easiest yes of my life” in her Instagram post on January 2, 2026. The couple shared photos of them kissing and enjoying a custom cake designed especially for the occasion, reading engaged.
This swift move from being on the road to reconciliation to engagement illustrates the intensity of the relationship’s previous experiences and the lessons learned from the past. The fans were overjoyed by the news, recognizing the truth in timing and second chances. This couple’s story demonstrates how a foundation in the past can empower move-forward decisions.
Stay tuned for more news and updates.
Also Read: Chad Powers: Key moments and fan reactions to the season’s biggest twists
Follow us on Instagram and Twitter.
Hilfa, Senior Writer at Hilvaro, excels in pop culture journalism. She crafts engaging content on movies, TV, & trends, fueled by her love for storytelling & entertainment.
Discover more from Hilvaro
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
One thought on “From Breakup to Bling: How Carli Bybel and Brett Caprioni Went From Rekindling Romance to Engagement in Under 90 Days.”